The Group whose aims are
'Good Governance' and 'Community Spirit'
in Sutton Bridge, Lincolnshire
A 15 minute Open Forum commenced at 7.00 p.m. with 8 Parishioners wishing to ask questions.
Business to be Transacted
1. Apologies for Absence with reasons: Apologies for absence were received from Cllr.S. Giles.
It was noted that Cllr.Brewis would be half-an-hour late.
2. Declarations of Interest:
3. Signing of the Minutes: Notes of 26th March 2013 meeting were agreed.
4. Police Matters: The PCSO reiterated her comments regarding the caravan on Bridge Road and said she was satisfied that the owner was trying to find a storage solution. There followed a lengthy discussion on the role of the Police Commissioner.
5. Chairman’s Remarks: Chairman remarked that he had attended the Planning Meeting at SHDC on 17th April and was not at all impressed. Those attendees, who were situated in Room 1 as there was insufficient room in the Council Chamber, could not see the plans. (At this point, Cllr.Hills pointed out that he hadn’t missed anything as the situation was the same in the Council Chamber). He added that the Incinerator application was to be discussed again at the next Planning Meeting on 8th May.
6. Clerk’s Report: Two youths caught on CCTV damaging Curlew Centre. Not enough evidence to convict. Full risk assessment being carried out on the Memorial Park Pavilion.
7. To Receive Reports from District & County Councillors: Written report from Cllr.M.Booth - briefly set out below:
8. Financial Matters: Finance Committee met earlier in the day.
(a) Four further payments to be made in addition to those listed on the Agenda. Cllr.Dewsberry said the reserves were healthy.
(b) Precept and allotment rents had been received.
(c) Accounts approved for year end 31/3/2013. These now available to anyone to read at the Parish Office – appointments required before viewing.
(d) Agreed to allocate £20,000 to reserves (i.e., £15,000 for burial ground and £5,000 for play equipment).
9. Correspondence:
(a) Clerk read out correspondence as listed on agenda. Commented that letter from Centrica available to all if required. SE Lincs Local Plan Consultation Exhibition at Curlew Centre 15th May, 3-7 pm. Power Station B – Modified proposals. Arrangements are being made for a public exhibition in the early summer. Pest Baiting around industrial units. Claims of rats within that locality. Drainage Board to fill in ‘grips’ and warning against digging these grips into watercourses. Burial Facilities – Now an urgent matter for this Council.
(b) Further correspondence available at Parish office.
10. Planning Matters: (i) New: - No comments. (ii) New: - No comments (Ref: H18-0246-13 Cllr.Rowe commented that perhaps the developers should be made aware of the proposed incinerator which would be close to this new development). (iii) Same comments apply as previous application.
11. Highways & Footpaths: Standard of work on tarmac repairs is appalling. Agreed to write to Lincs CC regarding repair work. Traffic restrictions at Tydd Road from 3-14th June. Diversions in operation. Comment made about lack of bus timetables.
12. To Receive Reports from Working Parties & Committees: (a) Knotweed still a problem. (b) Most of the allotment plots now looking better. (c) No meeting held. (d) Nothing to report. (e) Looking at another piece of land. (f) Nothing to report. (g) Nothing to report.
13. To Receive Reports from Outside Bodies: (a) Nothing to report. (b) Meeting held on 28th March. Precept same as last year. Urgently need voluntary drivers. (c) Confirmed toilets now taken over by SHDC. (d) Nothing to report. (e) Nothing to report. (f) Nothing to report. (g) Meeting to be arranged (h), (i), (j) and (k) Nothing to report. (l) Bank account finally opened after 6 month wait. ‘Needs Assessment’ form being revamped. (m) Youth Club attracting 20-30 people in two sessions. Need volunteer helpers.
14. To Receive update on matters relating to PREL Application: A lengthy discussion took place regarding the Planning Meeting held at SHDC on 17th April. It was generally agreed that the meeting under the chairmanship of Mr Gambba-Jones was appalling. Most Councillors did not understand the full implications of the proposal by PREL, had come to the meeting ill-prepared, lacked understanding of the major issues and were led in their decision by the Chair. Whilst Cllr. Jenny Rowe gave a presentation on behalf of Sutton Bridge PC, she had no support whatsoever from her fellow Sutton Bridge Councillor Chris Brewis. Had he supported her and the majority of Sutton Bridge residents who opposed this plan, it could well have meant that the application was thrown out. It was noted that the next meeting of the Planning Committee would be on 8th May and that this item would be first on the Agenda. In view of the urgency of this matter it was agreed by a majority that a letter should be written immediately to the Planning Committee urging them to put back the date of the next Planning Committee meeting. The Clerk and Cllr.Rowe to liaise on the content of the letter. Also agreed that if the date of the Planning Committee was put back, a further public meeting should be called by the PC and that leaflets should be distributed to all households. PC to meet the expense of the leaflets. Cllr.M. Booth abstained.
15. To Resolve on Parishioners Refurbishing Village Signs at West End and A.17: The Clerk showed a picture of the newly refurbished village sign on the village green. Agreed an excellent job had been done. Agreed that signs on A17 and west end of Bridge Road would be removed for refurbishment. Also agreed that the Parishioners involved should be offered recompense for their efforts.
16. To Resolve on further Action regarding Consultation re Local Plan: On reading the paperwork Cllr.Rowe commented that the PC should not proceed with this since it seemed that local people would have to do all the work while SHDC would take all the credit or cherry-pick whatever they wanted from any local proposals.
17. To Resolve on new Location in Memorial Park for Adult Exercise Equipment: Cllr.D.Grimwood said that original site has now proved unsuitable for a variety of reasons. New area for consideration is outside of the children’s play area in the park. Agreed.
18. Entering Best Kept Village 2013: Agreed.
19. Resolve on Action to be taken on Unfinished Triangle of land, rear of Curlew Centre:
Agreed that Friday Coffee Morning Ladies, the In-Bloom and some of the youth can clear and plant a wildflower meadow (as per email from Sutton Bridge in Bloom as read out by Clerk). PC to install a lockable post so that vehicle access can only be for emergency vehicles.
20. Resolve to confirm repair Works to Memorial Park Car Park: Agreed.
21. Consider Creating new Children’s Play Area: Deferred for time being.
22. Receive Requests from Members at Discretion of Chairman: Items raised under this heading will be put on Agenda for next meeting. Cllr.D.Grimwood raised objections to the recently issued Newsletter by Cllr.Brewis in which he claimed responsibility for curing the pothole situation. Cllr.Preston suggested there was no need for two football pitches in Memorial Park.
23. Resolve to move into Closed Session: Agreed, public left the meeting at 8.45 p.m
***********************************
NOTES FROM THE PUBLIC GALLERY:
Present: John Grimwood – Chairman
Cllr.Shirley Giles – Note Taker
1. Welcome - The Chairman welcomed all those attending the meeting and introduced Cllr.Shirley Giles as the Note-taker for the meeting in the absence of the Parish Clerk.
2. Signing of Minutes – Notes from the Parish Meeting held on 23rd November 2012 to be accepted as Minutes. Agreed
3. Report from Chairman of Parish Council
4. Report from Clerk to the Council – No report was given due to absence of Clerk.
5. Presentation – ‘Friends of Sutton Bridge Playing Fields & Open Spaces’. Mrs. Shirley Giles gave a presentation on behalf of ‘FSBPFOS’. She said that the group, although small in number had achieved a lot since inception. They had installed a number of benches in the village together with two picnic tables at the village green. These picnic tables had been well used over the past year. At present the group were seeking funding to install outdoor gym equipment in the Memorial Park alongside the Pavilion. She was seeking signatures of approval from the community as to need and use. This will help with their funding for the project.
6. Presentation – ‘Sutton Bridge in Bloom’. Mrs. Teresa Hardy gave a presentation on behalf of SBiB. She outlined the history of the group and said that at present SBiB consisted of 12 very active and busy members. The group had won a Silver Award for the community at the East Midlands in Bloom competition in 2012, but were not entering the competition this year in order to concentrate on current activities. She said that the group had a big project this year in the building of a Community Garden in the entrance area of the Memorial Park. Funding is being sought for this project. She went on to say that the group totally rely on funding and donations for their work – ‘no funding – no Sutton Bridge in Bloom’. The team are always looking for volunteers and would really like involvement from youngsters in the village. In conclusion, she thanked the Parish Council for their continued support.
7. Any Other Matters Members of the Public may wish to Raise
The meeting closed at 7.45 pm
Open Forum
Mr. Fenton stated that potholes in and around the Lime street area were getting larger and when filled with water could be a danger to cyclists.
He also stated that as the Walsingham Pilgrims were expected in the village and would be using the shower facilities in the Pavilion, that the surface at the entrance to the Memorial Park should be repaired as at present it was very muddy. It was pointed out that the ‘pilgrims’ were already here.
Cllr. Hills confirmed that new surface work would shortly be carried out in that area.
Mr. Collins-McDougal referred to the EDF Scoping document that had been presented to the PC and SHDC regarding the proposed building of Phase B, with a proposed output of 180 megawatts it would be double the size of the present Power Station. He further stated that he understood that EDF had sold out to an Australian company in December.
He said that EDF had been invited to make a presentation at the Annual Parish Meeting, and asked what steps does the PC intend to take to inform residents of this new proposed power station.
Mrs. Houlder also referred to the proposed construction of Phase B Gas fired Power Station stating that not only would air quality be at dangerously high levels if this proposal went ahead, but that the resulting increase in traffic would further add to the pollution of this area.
Mr. Blundell said:
Quote:
What I want to say concerns the parlous state of democracy in Sutton Bridge. It is highly unlikely that the PC will tell us anything about the proposed new power station any more than they told us about the incinerator.
Cllr Booth has been honest enough to say that he would support the incinerator development provided he could be reassured about the effect on air quality for Sutton Bridge. Unfortunately, since PREL assert that what they will burn is confidential, no such reassurances will be forthcoming. They could burn anything from rats’ tails to old socks in the future. It cannot be predicted what they will burn and so nobody can make a prediction about the likely effect on air quality. In addition to which an HGV going in and out of the proposed site every 5 minutes will have a disastrous effect on air quality quite apart from causing chaos on the roads.
In December I asked why Cllr Brewis declined to express a current opinion over the proposed PREL incinerator since, back in 2009 he seemed to be in favour of it. Through the Parish Clerk I have twice asked Cllr Brewis on what grounds he thinks he is exempt from the provision of the Localism Act which states that Councillors are no longer prevented from expressing an opinion on, for example, planning matters which they may be concerned with. I have not had the courtesy of a reply.
I asked the same kind of question in a letter to the Free Press. Again, no reply from Cllr Brewis. But I understand that he has made a response in his Newsletter which, since I'm on his blacklist, I do not receive. It described the letter as 'waffle'.
The intention of this new freedom in Localism Act was supposed to improve democratic discussion. (See page 5 in the simple person’s version of the Act)
I would like to know what the Parish Council's view of this example of ‘democratic interaction’ is where one of their number writes a resident’s expression of concern is written off as ‘waffle’. The fact is that in the continuing absence of a decent Parish Council Newsletter, the Brewis Newsletter is widely regarded as an organ of the Parish Council. To write a resident's concerns off as 'waffle' could be seen to be bringing the PC into disrepute.
What view does the PC have of this? I think it is important for the sake of democracy.
Unquote
At this point the substitute Clerk exceeded her role and took over chairpersonship of the meeting. She suggested that Mr Blundell was being unfair to the PC, that Cllr Brewis wrote his Newsletter under the role of District Councillor and that in any case while the Localism Act did say that that Councillors are no longer prevented from expressing an opinion on, for example, planning matters which they may be concerned with they were not obligated to express an opinion. She said this several times.
Mr Blundell emphasised his assertion that the Brewis Newsletter was to most people in Sutton Bridge a Parish Council publication and that because of that the PC appeared to be writing a resident’s letter off as ‘waffle’ - the PC should therefore have a view.
A lively discussion took place with Mr. Hawkins being accused of delivering his presentation so quickly it was impossible for the average person present to follow or even understand.
Cllr Croxford made the most important point that if two parts of the bank 600 metres apart were eventually fortified - made stronger than the rest of the bank - the stretch of wall between the first breach and the proposed second one would be more at risk. The sea would concentrate on the bit in between. Mr Hawkins said that he was not an expert on sea defences and he would refer this point to their technical experts.
Cllr Grimwood said his concern was the cracks that had appeared in the last breach made in the sea wall.
BUSINESS TO BE TRANSACTED
The Chairman stated that all seven of the wind turbines on the Grange Farm Wind Farm at Tydd Gote were now operational, the project having been completed ahead of schedule.
Jane Ripley, (standing in for Suzanne England) read the Clerk’s report. It was noted that CCV coverage at the Curlew Centre had been successful in identifying certain culprits.
DISTRICT COUNCILLORS REPORTS: A copy of District Councillor M. Booth’s report was handed out, main points as follows:
Finance: Cllr. Dewsberry gave a complicated and incomprehensible review of finances, and said there was plenty of money to cover all outstanding invoices.
A grant of £575.20 has been awarded to Friends of Sutton Bridge Playing Fields & Open Spaces.
Correspondence:
Planning Matters:
To resolve on Planning Consultation (Flood Risk Assessment) H18-0102-13 re the Race Bank Offshore Wind Farm.
The consideration of the PREL planning application for a Gasifier (incinerator) has been put back until the SHDC Planning Committee meeting in April.
Highways & Footpaths:
The Personnel Committee recommend that the Clerk purchases a new office chair to the value of £500.
SBCCF: Cllr. S. Booth reported it was being considered to put a lower ceiling in the main hall to resolve the sound effect.
The Grange Wind Farm turbines are now all up and running about a month ahead of schedule.
The Youth Club is desperate for volunteer leaders. A request was made to the local press present by the Chairman, Cllr. J. Grimwood, for people to come forward to offer to help.
Memorial Park: It was suggested that the hedged area of the Memorial Park from the car park gateway, past the Pavilion and beyond be cleared thus giving considerably more space. Consideration is to be given as to the best way to do this, either by using the Pay Back Scheme or hiring a contractor.
Cllr. Dewsberry stated that the ambulance service was letting down many parishioners, two notable cases recently being a 2 hour wait for a 1 yr old child, and an ambulance was not available to take a 90 yr old who had had a fall, even though this person had been taken to the local Health centre and a doctor had called for an ambulance.
Cllr Hills reported the very prompt ambulance service that she had received.
***********************************
FROM THE PUBLIC GALLERY:
Open Forum
The meeting began with a minute’s silence in respect for a former Chairman of the PC, Mr. Bert Goode, who had recently died.
Lynn Harrison, reporter for the Lincs Free Press, reported the successful candidate for their Smile Competition was Mrs. Jan Denwood from the Sutton Bridge Pharmacy, who had won against much competition within the South Holland area.
Plans are being put in place for Lynn Harrison to be in either Long Sutton or Sutton Bridge on a weekly basis to encourage local residents to give their views on local issues or stories of local heroes that may be used to promote and publicise these two areas.
BUSINESS TO BE TRANSACTED
Sgt. Laura Grigson reported to date the vandals who damaged the PC’s letter box and the lights at the Curlew Centre had not been caught.
The Chairman reported that the area behind the industrial units in Railway Lane had been cleared.
Cllr. M. Booth reported that fly tipping was still a problem in the Woad Lane area.
Cllr. Brewis made a long report on the subject of the EMAS and other areas of the NHS where services were lacking.
In Financial Matters, several more expenses had been incurred, including the cost of repairing the fence in the children’s play area in the Memorial Park by Lutton Fencing.
A grant of £500 has been awarded to the Sutton Bridge in Bloom group
A grant of £357 has been awarded to the Sutton Bridge Youth Club.
Cllr. Rowe asked where the equipment taken from the old youth club building is being stored. Apparently there is no trace of it. Some of the equipment was allegedly stored in Holbeach and some in Spalding. Enquiries have been made without success of finding any of the missing equipment.
More notices regarding the offence of allowing dogs to foul public areas are to be posted on the Falklands estate.
A re-scoping document from EDF was given to all councillors regarding a proposed second gas fired power station on land adjacent to the present one. EDF are planning an exhibition in the village in May. With the Annual Parish Meeting being held end of April, it was decided to invite a representative to give a presentation then.
Highways and Footways – Sutton Bridge has an enormous number of potholes being reported.
The matter of the surface water at the two zebra crossings in the village will be attended to.
A suggestion has been put forward to place benches in the Falklands Estate area.
Cllr. Grimwood reported on a recent meeting of the K.L.Advisory Group that it had been decided to leave the marsh to regenerate on its own.
It is understood that the PREL planning application will be put before the Planning Committee in March. Several councillors question whether it is known from which source PREL will get their fuel. It was asked if they will be using Port Sutton Bridge and if so were the Highways aware of that suggestion? It also remains for PREL to advise where they intend to source their fuel.
The Marina Project - it appears the problem of the land ownership remains unresolved.
The Snow Goose Project – is presently still ongoing.
The CCTV problem remains unsatisfactory. If the CCTV cameras are working in Sutton Bridge there has been no recorded reliable evidence of the vandalism being caused in the village. Cllr. Brewis to take the matter up again at the SHDC meeting.
Christmas lights – a quotation had been received for improving the Christmas light display at the east end of the village. The PC considered this a little too expensive at the present time.
Friends of Sutton Bridge Playing Fields and Open Spaces have made several proposals for the PC’s consideration:
The art work presented for consideration for the refurbishment of the village signs was met with more derision than approval. It was suggested that perhaps the pupils of Peele School be invited to submit artwork.
With regard to the production of a further edition of the Parish Newsletter it was suggested that Mr. Brandon-King, his not being a parish councillor, should not be involved in the production of it. Several councillors offered themselves to join the committee. Suzanne pointed out that this would involve organising the layout of the Newsletter as well as liaising with the publishers etc.
Requests from Councillors for consideration of the Chairman:
Public were requested to leave the chamber at 9.20 pm.
Open Forum
Ms. C. Bunnage spoke of Christmas lights and showed the PC photographs of what could be provided at the east end of the village. Costs would include maintenance.
Mr. Fenton compared the Council Tax charges from 1979 when he paid £2 per week and the village was kept neat and tidy, roads swept regularly and no litter, to the present day when he pays £20 per week when the village roads are in a disgusting state with autumn leaves still in gutters and people having to walk through water on footpaths in the main road as the drains are not cleared.
He also mentioned that he had contacted LCC about the salt bins on West Bank being empty, only to be referred to SHDC. Each had said it was not their remit to fill salt bins. However, after he had complained again he found that the bins had been refilled the next day.
His final complaint was about a report in the local papers about the state the football pavilion had been left in after a football match. He considered this unfair as it was impossible for the cleaner to tackle the problem at that time of night. Mr. Fenton also stated that the person who cleans the pavilion does so on a voluntary basis and receives no recompense.
BUSINESS TO BE TRANSACTED
A presentation given by Dr. Steven Dykes (Deputy Medical Director, and Alison Crowe (Service Delivery Manager) on the East Midlands Ambulance Service was given. Details of new plans in the area covered were outlined and residents were assured their complaints about the ambulance service were being noted.
On Police Matters it was reported that the matter of the stolen lights and post box were still being investigated. With the new Police Commissioner now being in office, it was suggested that he be approached for plans for Sutton Bridge in connection with youth vandalism. The PC is also to request an explanation of the police hierarchy from the new Commissioner.
Cllr. M. Booth also stated the new Commissioner was supportive of a county run CCTV scheme.
In the Chairman's remarks it was stated that up to 18 local parish councils had been invited to a meeting at the Curlew Centre, together with representatives of PREL as well as two members from the action group.
It was also noted that work is much in evidence on the Grange Wind Farm with the first turbine having been erected.
In the Clerk's report she advised there had been several letters of thanks from various other Parish Councils for the informative meeting that had been recently held with PREL.
The area on which the Youth Club had stood is to be seeded.
Lincs Highways were considering the proposed bus shelters for Bridge Road and had pointed out some proposed shelters were situated directly in front of houses and thus may give rise to complaints from the owners.
The Clerk also advised of a Bus Shelter Grant Scheme whereby a successful application could mean a saving of 50% of the cost.
Cllr. M. Booth stated that fly tipping was still going on and that the Woad Lane area is the worst. Residents are requested to keep a lookout and to report suspected vehicles to the police.
Hare coursing is not so bad, though this may be due to the success of arrests by the police and the recent bad weather.
The matter of the Travellers site is still on going and work is expected to start on schedule, but as yet contracts have not been issued.
There is much concern about the new Bedroom Tax, applicable to people living in rented accommodation. Tenants would have to pay extra and there would be reduced benefits.
The next SBMAG meeting is scheduled for 11th February, 6.30 pm at the Curlew Centre.
Under the Financial Matters Cllr. Dewsberry gave an up to date report. He stated that it had been agreed over several committee meetings that the 2013-1014 Precept will be £59,000.
Referring to the CCTV invoice dispute, a credit note for half the amount had been received. It is alleged there is no CCTV working in the village, and if there is it has not been monitored. There has been no action taken or anybody charged for the vandalism occurring in the village, or CCTV footage used in evidence. It is considered the parish is not getting value for the money the system costs.
In correspondence a cheque for £3,500 had been received from the Head of Libraries and Heritage towards the Library in the Curlew Centre, offset by the withdrawal of the Mobile Library service tot the three stops in the village.
The rumble strips on the A17 are having an adverse effect on the village as many more vehicles are now passing through Sutton Bridge rather than use the bypass.
King John Bank will be closed for one day only between end February and early march 2013.
The contributions to the Voluntary Car scheme remains the same. More voluntary drivers are required.
The Youth Club is now held in the Curlew Centre on a regular basis. Numbers attending have been disappointing, but this could be due to the recent bad weather.
Cllr. Mrs. Rowe has been registered to speak at the Planning meeting considering the PREL planning application at SHDC.
A negative response from SHDC had been received to the letter sent by the SBPC requesting an independent Environmental Impact Assessment.
It had previously been alleged that the air pollution in Sutton Bridge is currently almost at maximum level and if the new development goes ahead this could put it above the safety level. The suggestion being that if that should happen then the EA would close the plant down. Cllr. Croxford stated it would be preferable to have accurate measures taken before the proposed gasifier/incinerator was built, rather than after.
Cllr. M. Booth spoke of his concern regarding the S106 funding, as if this is not spent before 2015, then it would have to be returned to the Power Station. The two projects, namely the Marina Project and the Snowgoose Trust applications have not yet been started. It had been intimated the Marina would be built by December 2012, but now is projected for second half 2013. It would appear that to date there had been no response from the Snowgoose Trust to questions raised regarding their application. Matter to be put on next agenda.
A letter had been received from the Manager of the Health Centre regarding the provision of an outside shelter. Lincolnshire Primary Care Trust own the building, and they feel that since the Health Centre is already the target of much vandalism, outside shelter would add to this. A solution to the problem of early morning patients having to wait outside in all weathers is still being sought.
Decision is still to be made where to erect the new Notice Board donated by Wingland Foods. Posts have also been supplied.
The position of the bus stop on the north side of the A17 will remain unchanged. Highways Dept consider it would be too dangerous to place it nearer to the East Bank.
Authorisation is being given to the Parishioner's request to undertake the refurbishment of emblems on the village sign near the old Metalair Works fence. The local art group are also working on designs for the two signs at each end of the village.
Archived notes for previous Parish Council meetings held in 2012 can now be viewed HERE